Provident Financial still too expensive for RBC Capital

Oliver Haill WebFG News | 14 Sep, 2017 10:37 | | |

cbprovident
  • 911.50
  • 1.05%9.50
  • Max: 925.00
  • Min: 893.00
  • Volume: 1,031,832
  • MM 200 : n/a
17:17 21/11/17
  • 7,411.34
  • 0.30%21.88
  • Max: 7,422.18
  • Min: 7,367.86
  • Volume: 0
  • MM 200 : n/a
17:20 21/11/17
  • 10,694.90
  • 0.66%70.39
  • Max: 10,733.67
  • Min: 10,611.92
  • Volume: 0
  • MM 200 : n/a
17:20 21/11/17
  • 4,121.97
  • 0.31%12.66
  • Max: 4,127.16
  • Min: 4,098.05
  • Volume: 0
  • MM 200 : n/a
17:20 21/11/17
  • 4,070.45
  • 0.31%12.40
  • Max: 4,075.50
  • Min: 4,047.46
  • Volume: 0
  • MM 200 : n/a
17:30 21/11/17

Even after losing almost three quarters of its value in the last three months Provident Financial shares are still too expensive, RBC Capital Markets said on Thursday as it downgraded the doorstep lender to an 'underperform' rating.

RBC, which set a 775p share price target that compares to an 846p closing price a day earlier and the 3,000p level seen in early June, set out seven reasons why it was downgrading the shares.

Provident's attempted restructuring, where it is trying to replace its self-employed door-to-door collection agents with an army of full-time workers, was "rushed" and despite two profit warnings "it is questionable whether the company’s issues are under control".

RBC stressed that there "is no certainty the turnaround in home credit will be successful" for a division that generated £115m profit before tax in 2016 and will is expected to have a £80-120m loss in 2017.

An investigation by the Financial Conduct Authority into the hitherto lucrative repayment option plan (ROP) sold by the group's Vanquis Bank arm, which has similar characteristics to PPI, is now estimated to face a potential financial impact, including customer redress, FCA penalties and the cost of administering the situation, of as much as £300m.

Furthermore the financial impact from not selling the ROP, which contributed £50m to 2016 adjusted PBT, could also be greater expected.

"The group's financial covenants are tight and could be breached if the FCA redress is as significant as we expect," which analysts warned "could impact the ability to pay dividends for years".

Other, no less important factors to consider are that the company has not ruled out an equity raise and that credit agencies are "likely" to downgrade its debt to non-investment grade, thereby increasing funding costs.

Anticipating further home credit downgrades and reduced Vanquis earnings given the run-off of ROP income, RBC cut its forecasts for earnings per share for the current and next two financial years by 65%, 56% and 42% to 51.7p, 81.7p and 125.3p respectively.

More news

18:36 Numis sticks to 'hold' on Entertainment One after strong first half performance

Analysts at Numis Securities said "robust progress" evident in Canadian entertainment company Entertainment One's first-half trading results led it to the reiteration of its 'hold' rating and target price.

18:28 Europe close: Shares end near session highs

Stocks finished near their best levels of the day, possibly influenced by the latest German poll results which might help coax the country's politicians to return to the negotiating table in order to help thrash out a stable government coalition - or face the voters again.

18:08 Faroe Petroleum issues $100m senior, unsecured bond in Nordic bond market

The independent oil and gas company, Faroe Petroleum, announced on Tuesday the issue of a $100m senior, unsecured bond in the Nordic bond market, in an attempt to strengthen the company's balance sheet.

17:56 FX round-up: UK trade budget widens as greenback trades on the backfoot

Data out for the UK on Tuesday showed an unexpectedly wider budget deficit, while in the US, the dollar weakened 0.17% to 93.923 against a basket of currencies.

18:02 London close: FTSE higher on the day as UK deficit widens unexpectedly

Shares closed higher on Tuesday as data revealed an unexpected widening of the UK deficit ahead of the Autumn Budget.

17:38 Improved Asia-Pacific trading puts Spirax-Sarco in line with full-year targets

Industrial engineer Spirax-Sarco stayed on track to hit full-year expectations as sales in the four months leading to 31 October were boosted by growth in Asia Pacific, though offered limited visibility for 2018 due to the usual short-term nature of its order book.

17:27 US open: S&P 500 and Nasdaq Composite at fresh record highs

The S&P 500 and tech-laden Nasdaq Composite are pushing to fresh record highs amid a 'bullish' call on stocks out of Goldman and against a backdrop of supportive economic data.

17:04 JPMorgan upgrades ITV as European broadcaster concerns 'overstated'

UK broadcaster ITV was boosted by an upgrade from investment bank JPMorgan Cazenove, which views the European sector as markedly undervalued by the market, with addressable-TV a development that "will transform TV" for advertisers.

16:52 Investec cuts water company price target due to nationalisation threat

United Utilities could be forced to slash its dividend from 2020 due to new regulation, warned Investec, leading it to downgrade its rating on the water company, and cut target prices across the sector.

17:48 Robert Mugabe resigns as president of Zimbabwe

President Mugabe has handed in a written letter of resignation, putting a halt to impeachment hearings, the speaker of Zimbabwe's parliament said on Tuesday.